When it comes to taking public transit and doing errands, re-wrapping an EC’d baby/toddler multiple times, whilst juggling grocery bags is cumbersome and inefficient. So, for days when I know I will be taking transit and running errands, I always use my soft structured carrier (Ergo). From a minimalist perspective, I think that a sling and soft structured carrier would have been ideal for us from the beginning. However, I have found my wraps to be quite useful especially during those times when my son was teething or needing to be rocked to sleep.
In retrospect, I should have purchased a ring sling or a shorter wrap, but at the time I thought that ring slings looked fairly difficult and I did not recognize the advantage of a shorter wrap. For us mothers who do practice EC with our babies, the importance of being able to take one’s baby out of the carrier quickly, especially when they are younger, is key to making EC workable.
The point is, when looking at what type of carrier or wrap, one needs to think about lifestyle firstly and then purchase accordingly. Asking questions such as: do you plan to practice EC or simply [cloth] diaper your baby? Do you take public transit, or own a car or are you part of a car co-op? These kind of questions, as well as connecting with other babywearing mamas can help you determine what type of carrier or wrap is best suited for you and your baby’s needs.